Utah's Own Logo

Must Be Nuts

Hand-crafted small batch peanut butter treats, with carefully hand stirred ingredients and topped for a unique experience every time

We make handcrafted small batch peanut butters, they are a treat/dessert.
The texture of our peanut butter “Smunchy” isn’t quite smooth but not quite crunchy, that’s why we like to call it Smunchy. Our others are more thick like an edible cookie dough. We do not add any preservatives to our peanut butter and it is common to see oil on top of natural peanut butters. Some flavors gain more oil than others depending on the consistency and mix-ins. The only preservatives come from the mix-ins.
We frequently get asked how do you eat this?
Well most just grab a spoon and eat if right out of the jar, you can use some as a spread on toast/waffles, or use as a dip for apples, pretzels, orgraham crackers, top your favorite icecream with it or eat it in yogurt. The possibilities are endless!
Shelf life of our product is unopened: 6 months. Opened: 30 days (but let’s be real, it won’t last that
long)

Our peanut butter doesn’t need to be refrigerated it can actually change the quality of the product, so we don’t recommend refrigerating. We also do offer some gluten free options but in our small-batch kitchen we do use gluten products and try to ensure no cross contamination with proper cleaning processes.

Shop & Learn More

Can be Found Here:

  • Currently only online, we offer free local pickup at The Nut Garden in Bluffdale when you choose local pickup on our website.

Reviews:

“Wow!!!!!!! I bought 3. The original, the great pumpkin butter and churrolicious!!! All are delicious. The consistency of the peanut butter is absolutely perfect.” – Jennifer, Facebook Review

“The hype is real! This is something you can just eat directly out of the tub with a spoon, it’s that great. If you love peanut butter you HAVE to get this. The favor balance is quite perfect. The consistency is also.” – CJ, Facebook Review

Contact Information
Owner Information
Amber & Todd Huber
Co-Owners

Hi, we’re The Huber’s (Amber and Todd) 👋
We are just a regular couple navigating this crazy world while trying to raise 3 kids to be good humans. Earlier this year (June 2024), we decided to turn a fun hobby into a side hustle: crafting and selling our fresh handmade peanut butter at local farmers markets. What started as a little extra income to offset rising costs (thanks, inflation!) quickly grew into something much bigger than we ever imagined.

We signed up for markets through @good4lifemarkets (highly recommend them if you’re in Utah!) and began selling in June. On September 30th, during one of our last farmers markets of the season, something incredible happened. It was a slower evening, and after packing up, we headed home, as usual, to tally up the day’s sales. That night, I started getting messages on our Instagram and Facebook business pages from people out of state asking how to buy our peanut butter. Honestly, I thought it was some kind of scam! Then, a potential customer messaged me about a TikTok video featuring someone crying over our peanut butter. Curious, we watched it—and wow, what a surprise! It was hilarious, heartwarming, and surreal to see someone enjoying our Churrolicious flavor so much. At that point, the video already had over 250,000 views! 🤯 Turns out, a customer that evening had shared her husband’s emotional reaction to tasting our peanut butter for the first time—and the video took off. These last few weeks have been a whirlwind of emotions, excitement, and figuring out how to keep up with the demand. We’re so grateful for the outpouring of love, support, and patience as we work hard to fulfill all the pre-orders. ❤️

We’re thrilled to continue this journey and can’t wait to release more peanut butter flavors for you to enjoy—maybe even one that brings you happy tears, too. 🥹

Much love,
Amber & Todd 🫶

Line drawing of a broccoli headLine drawing of an eggplant